Alma and Headway structure their fees differently, making a direct comparison tricky — but here is the bottom line for 2026:
- Alma charges a flat $125/month membership — your session revenue stays with you
- Headway takes a percentage of each reimbursement (estimated 10–15% by therapist reports)
- At low volume (<12 sessions/week), Headway is cheaper. At high volume (>18 sessions/week), Alma wins
- Neither platform discloses what payer rates they negotiate on your behalf
- The real comparison is platform cost vs independent credentialing cost — not Alma vs Headway
- Direct billing with professional support typically beats both platforms at 15+ sessions/week
The question therapists actually want answered — “which platform puts more money in my pocket?” — is surprisingly hard to find a straight answer to. Both Alma and Headway are deliberately opaque about their fee structures, and the answer genuinely depends on your session volume, your CPT code mix, and your geographic market.
This post builds a real comparison from first principles: what Alma charges, what Headway likely charges, and how both stack up against the alternative of billing independently. For the broader platform comparison including EHR, community, and referral features, see our Alma vs Headway vs Grow Therapy overview.
How Each Platform Makes Money
Alma charges a flat monthly membership fee — $125/month for solo therapists as of 2026. This fee covers credentialing support, billing infrastructure, EHR access, and the peer community. When your insurance claim is paid, 100% of that reimbursement goes to you. The platform cost is fixed, regardless of how many sessions you see.
Headway charges no monthly fee. Instead, Headway keeps a percentage of each insurance reimbursement it collects on your behalf. The exact percentage is not published, but consistent therapist reports across practitioner communities put the figure between 10% and 15%. At a $175 average 90837 rate, that is $17.50 to $26.25 per session going to Headway.
Payout Comparison by Session Volume
The table below models the annual platform cost at three session volumes, assuming a $175 average 90837 rate and a 12% Headway fee. Adjust the Headway % up or down based on your actual contract.
| Sessions/Week | Alma Annual Cost | Headway Annual Cost (12%) | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|
| 8 sessions | $1,500 | $8,736 | Alma saves $7,236 |
| 12 sessions | $1,500 | $13,104 | Alma saves $11,604 |
| 15 sessions | $1,500 | $16,380 | Alma saves $14,880 |
| 20 sessions | $1,500 | $21,840 | Alma saves $20,340 |
| 25 sessions | $1,500 | $27,300 | Alma saves $25,800 |
At virtually every session volume, Alma’s flat fee beats Headway’s percentage model — assuming the same underlying payer rates. The risk is that the payer rates Alma negotiates may be lower than what Headway would pay for the same code, narrowing or eliminating the advantage.
Real-World Scenarios
👤 Part-Time Therapist (8 sessions/week)
Headway at 12% costs $21/session on a $175 rate. Alma is the clear winner at low volume — IF the payer rates are comparable.
💼 Full-Time Therapist (20 sessions/week)
Headway costs $21/session. Alma saves over $20,000/year. But at 20 sessions/week, independent credentialing saves even more.
The Option That Beats Both: Direct Credentialing
A full-time therapist on any platform is paying a significant annual fee — either in cash (Alma) or in percentage (Headway). Independent credentialing with professional billing support eliminates the platform cut entirely.
The process: get your NPI number, complete your CAQH ProView profile, and apply directly to Aetna, UnitedHealthcare, Cigna, and BCBS. The timeline is 60–120 days per payer. Once approved, your billing service collects on every claim and you keep 100% of the reimbursement.
Our billing bundle at $499/month includes credentialing, claim submission, denial management, and payment posting — all for a fixed monthly fee that becomes cheaper per session the busier your practice gets.
🔍 Calculate Your Platform Savings →
Exclusive Provider Bundle
Everything your practice needs — one simple monthly investment
- Professional Medical Billing
- FREE Insurance Credentialing
- FREE TherapyDial Profile Listing
- Priority Practice Support
No setup fees • Cancel anytime
Stop Paying the Platform Cut
Our credentialing specialists respond within 1 business day.
